ECB threatens Ashes ban for BBC commentators over Pat Cummins-backed YouTube venture

The ECB's warning over The Usual Voices has escalated into a dispute over cricket broadcast rights, with commentators considering legal action and the show's organisers seeking talks with the governing body.

Australian cricket captain Pat Cummins and ECB chief executive Richard Gould pictured alongside the England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) and BBC Sport logos.

The England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) has threatened to block several prominent BBC cricket commentators from covering the 2027 Ashes if they participate in a new YouTube watchalong during England’s tour of South Africa, according to an exclusive report by The Telegraph‘s Will Macpherson.

The proposed programme, The Usual Voices (TUV), is backed by an Australian media venture co-founded by Pat Cummins and would feature familiar voices from BBC Test Match Special (TMS). ECB Chief Executive Richard Gould has raised concerns that the production could undermine the value of exclusive radio rights purchased by Talksport.

The warning has created a potential legal dispute, with commentators involved in the project examining their options should the ECB refuse them accreditation for next summer’s Ashes.

The commercial dispute behind the ECB’s warning

The controversy centres on Talksport’s acquisition of UK radio rights for England’s upcoming tour of South Africa from Cricket South Africa (CSA). The BBC holds the rights for England’s current tour of Australia but will not provide its usual TMS coverage during the South Africa series.

For the ECB, the concern extends beyond the immediate competition between two commentary services. The governing body regards payments from official broadcasters as an important source of income for international cricket.

Gould told Telegraph Sport: “We are aware for the South Africa tour that broadcast rights have been purchased by Talksport. For the current Australia tour they have been purchased by the BBC. The money that has been paid is important to the economics of cricket. We want to help protect CSA’s income streams, because they rely on those to pay their players and fund the game in South Africa.”

The ECB is particularly concerned about a professional commentary operation featuring established broadcasters rather than individuals independently discussing cricket online. Gould has indicated that the board would take a similar position against other groups of commentators whose activities it considered damaging to official broadcasting agreements.

His comments also establish a potential consequence beyond the South Africa tour, with the ECB prepared to exercise its authority over access to English cricket grounds.

Gould stated: “We are against anything that undermines the value of those broadcast rights. And whilst of course there will be legal angles that can be looked at, on the face of it you have something that is basically perceived to be a rip-off radio station intending to cover Test matches in South Africa. There are other protections available to us which includes the ability to control media accreditation into our venues in our own summer. And we would certainly do that for any commentators that are perceived to be undermining the broadcast values either for us, or our fellow countries.”

England’s home Ashes series against Australia is scheduled to run from June 18 to August 2, 2027.

Inside the Pat Cummins-backed media venture

The Usual Voices is being developed by Cricket Entertainment Network (CEN), an Australian company co-founded by Australia Test Captain Pat Cummins and his agent Neil Maxwell.

Its proposed format would see commentators based in a London studio following matches on television and providing live discussion and alternative commentary through YouTube. The company also plans to extend the format to other cricket competitions.

Eight regular TMS contributors have agreed to participate: Phil Tufnell, Steven Finn, Daniel Norcross, Alex Hartley, Vic Marks, Andy Zaltzman, Ebony Rainford-Brent and Simon Mann. Former England Captain David Gower and Simon Hughes, neither of whom works for the BBC, are also involved in the proposed line-up.

The BBC has not objected to its regular contributors pursuing the opportunity, with the absence of TMS assignments during the South Africa tour leaving them available for other work.

CEN maintains that its proposed service can operate without using protected match footage or audio, distinguishing its model from an unauthorised reproduction of an official broadcast.

In a statement to Telegraph Sport, CEN said: “Our broadcasters talk about cricket for a living. They love the game. They respect broadcasters’ rights. They also have to work. Watchalong shows are common nowadays. If CEN don’t copy match footage or audio or infringe anyone’s rights, our understanding is that it is legal to stream a watchalong. In fact, they enrich the fan experience, offer a platform for talent who would otherwise be unheard, and are good for sport.”

The company has also cited the BBC’s previous Cricket Social broadcasts as an example of comparable programming. Those shows covered England tours of Sri Lanka in 2018, the West Indies in 2019 and India in 2021 from a studio in Salford.

Ashes accreditation threat raises legal questions

According to The i Paper, commentators associated with The Usual Voices are exploring potential legal action against the ECB if they are prevented from covering the Ashes.

Those involved believe a refusal of accreditation could provide grounds for a restraint-of-trade challenge under UK employment law. One commentator, speaking anonymously to The i Paper, described the group as having been taken aback by Gould’s warning.

The ECB told The i Paper that decisions over media accreditation are within its discretion and that a commentator would not necessarily have to violate specific accreditation conditions to be refused access.

The situation creates particular complications for freelance broadcasters whose professional assignments extend across different media organisations and cricket events.

CEN has argued that restrictions imposed over participation in its programme would affect commentators’ ability to pursue other employment.

The company added in a statement to Telegraph Sport.: “The team also take jobs around the world to earn a living. Withholding the broadcasters’ accreditation would prevent them earning a living when they are doing nothing wrong. CEN would welcome talking to the ECB to understand their position which currently feels like a concern to all journalists.”

Among the prospective participants is Rainford-Brent, who also serves on the ECB board.

ECB and CEN remain divided over broadcast rights

Gould has discussed the controversy with representatives of CSA, Talksport and the BBC while attending an International Cricket Council meeting in Bali.

Addressing how recently the proposed production had come to the ECB’s attention, Gould told Telegraph Sport: “It’s something we have heard more about in the last 24 hours.”

At that stage, he had not spoken directly to CEN or the commentators involved in the project.

The ECB Chief Executive has also defended the governing body’s position on the financial obligations associated with official media partnerships.

Gould said: “It’s about protecting our rights holders and making sure the finances of the game are not undermined by people who believe they have the rights to something without paying for it.”

The disagreement has not yet resulted in confirmed legal proceedings or formal accreditation restrictions.

Uncertainty remains ahead of England’s South Africa tour

England’s visit to South Africa includes three Tests beginning on December 17, 2026, followed by three One-Day Internationals concluding on January 15, 2027.

According to The i Paper, CEN had repeatedly sought discussions with the ECB without securing a response, while the prospective commentators had not signed contracts for the tour at the time of publication.

The ECB’s position has therefore left the proposed production facing uncertainty before its planned launch.

With no confirmed resolution between the governing body and CEN, the dispute remains unresolved ahead of England’s South Africa series and the subsequent 2027 Ashes.

,