Intro
Usman Khawaja’s autobiography, Sabr, places the origin of Sandpapergate a test earlier than Cricket Australia’s 2018 findings did — in the dressing room at Port Elizabeth, where he writes that sandpaper was “discovered to be effective.” He says Steve Smith “threw his hands in the air and said he didn’t want to know,” that an unnamed coach told Cameron Bancroft in Cape Town “we need more of it,” and that the whole touring party should have accepted collective responsibility. Darren Lehmann denies being that coach. Mitchell Starc says his recollection has not changed since 2021. David Warner, breaking an eight-year silence, calls Khawaja’s account “100% accurate.”
The detail that cuts deepest is procedural: Khawaja says he sat beside Bancroft for the whole test and was never interviewed. Chief executive Todd Greenberg — who, as Players Association chief in 2021, was among those Khawaja approached about collective responsibility — says there is “no compelling reason” to reopen the file, while acknowledging he has not yet read the book.
Reopening it would mean investigating Pat Cummins, Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon, the four who signed a 2021 statement denying knowledge and who remain the core of the test side, weeks before a home series against New Zealand. A cricexec audience poll on whether the investigation should be reopened currently sits at exactly 50/50. In the vlog below, cricexec founder and publisher Zee Zaidi works through both sides.
Transcript
In 2018, three Australian cricketers took the blame for Sandpapergate. Three players out of an entire touring squad. This week, another member of that dressing room, Usman Khawaja, put it this way, quote, “It was all of us. Not the batters, not the bowlers, not the staff, all of us.” And David Warner, one of the three who were banned, says Khawaja’s account is, quote, “100% accurate.” Cricket Australia’s response? There’s no compelling reason to look at it again. Everyone remembers it differently, so what would be the point? That’s an interesting argument. Settling conflicting accounts is the whole reason investigations exist.
I’m Zee Zaidi, founder and publisher of cricexec, the leading publication covering the business of cricket worldwide. We’re read daily by the people who run the sport, boards, franchises, sponsors, and players, and those people are split. We asked our audience whether Cricket Australia should reopen its 2018 investigation. Right now, the result is exactly 50/50.
To understand why, you have to go back to Cape Town. March 2018, Australia are playing South Africa at Newlands in a series that’s already been bad-tempered. On the third day, the television cameras catch the opening batter, Cameron Bancroft, working the ball with something in his hand and then tucking it down his trousers while Australia were fielding. At first, it was described as yellow tape, but it was sandpaper. That evening, the captain, Steve Smith, sat next to Bancroft in a press conference and admitted that the team’s, quote, “leadership group” had known about the plan.
What followed was one of the biggest crises Australian cricket or any cricket board has ever had. It became a national story and not just a sports story, and it hit the business of the game straight away. Magellan walked away from its naming rights deal for the test series. Smith and Warner lost personal sponsors.
Within days, Cricket Australia had its findings. Smith was found to have known about the plan and not stopped it. Warner was found to be central to developing it. Both were banned for 12 months. Bancroft was banned for nine. Smith lost the captaincy, and Warner was banned from leadership roles for life. The coach, Darren Lehmann, wasn’t sanctioned, but resigned within days. And that was it. Three players. Nobody else in the squad was found to have known.
It didn’t stay settled that way. In 2021, Bancroft was asked by The Guardian whether the bowlers knew. His answer, quote, “I think it’s probably self-explanatory.” Within days, the four frontline bowlers from Cape Town, Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood, and Nathan Lyon, put out a joint statement. They said they prided themselves on their honesty and, quote, “We did not know a foreign substance was taken onto the field to alter the condition of the ball.” Unquote. They also pointed out that the umpires had inspected the ball and found no damage. That’s the account Cricket Australia has stood behind ever since.
Now, here’s Khawaja’s. In his autobiography, “Sabr”, he says the story starts a test earlier in Port Elizabeth. He says the team was talking about reverse swing in the dressing room at St. George’s Park, and that sandpaper was, in his word, quote, “discovered to be effective.” He describes a plan to use it when the ball went to the boundary at moments when the umpires and the cameras were looking elsewhere. He writes, quote, “We all knew that the umpire would drop the ball on the boundary as we went out onto the field.” He says Warner said he wouldn’t do it himself. He says Bancroft, who was just six tests into his career, volunteered. And on the captain, he writes, quote, “It was at this point Steve Smith essentially threw his hands in the air and said he didn’t want to know.”
Then Cape Town. Khawaja says that after Australia were bowled out for 255, a coach said this to Bancroft, quote, “Bangers, whatever you’re doing, we need more of it. It’s wet out there. We just need more of it.” Unquote. Khawaja doesn’t name the coach. Darren Lehmann says it wasn’t him and that he knew nothing about it.
Khawaja’s central argument is that the whole touring party should have accepted collective responsibility. His words, quote, “Take this as a team.” Unquote. He’s since clarified that doesn’t mean everyone took part, but he won’t deny that many knew. He says the team manager told him that two players were against the idea of collective responsibility. Khawaja doesn’t name them, but he writes, quote, “I knew who those two guys were, and it was ludicrous. Out of everyone, it was them.”
And then there’s the detail that matters most. Khawaja says, quote, “I was sitting next to Cam Bancroft that whole test match, and I didn’t get interviewed.”
So why is he only saying this now? He says he wrote down his recollections back in 2018 and wanted to speak after the bans, but Steve Smith talked him out of it. As he put it, quote, “I wasn’t going to go to war with those guys back then. I just wasn’t comfortable. That’s the truth.” He says he waited until he’d retired, which he did this past January, and until after Australia’s recent tour of South Africa, so he wouldn’t disrupt the team. He says Pat Cummins had no objection to the book. Cummins confirms that, saying his message to Khawaja was, “Tell your story. It’s fine.” And Khawaja has flatly denied doing this for book sales. He says his publisher, Penguin, didn’t even know this chapter existed until he handed over the final draft. And as he put it, quote, “I haven’t thrown anyone under the bus.”
Which brings us to Warner. Warner and Khawaja have been friends since they were little kids. Khawaja says that’s the real reason he wrote this, quote, “I made a promise to my childhood friend, David Warner, that I would tell the truth so he could tell his story.” And for eight years, Warner has carried more of the blame for Sandpapergate than anyone. He’s barely spoken about it at all.
Then this week, he posted a video. Quote, “It’s been eight years since I’ve spoken on this topic, and Uzzy, I throw my full support behind you.” On the investigation, he didn’t hold back. Quote, “Uzzy was not interviewed. How is that a thorough investigation? It baffles me.” Warner talked about what this has done to his family and to Smith and Bancroft, and he insisted, quote, “We’re not here to point fingers, and we’re not opening old wounds.” His point was that people should stop scrutinizing Khawaja and start asking the people who ran the investigation to account for it. Khawaja’s book also makes clear how Warner felt about the bowler’s 2021 statement. In Khawaja’s words, quote, “This really pissed me off, but not as much as it pissed Davey off.”
Not everyone is backing Khawaja. Darren Lehmann says, quote, “I don’t think everyone would have known.” And then on Tuesday, Mitchell Starc said his recollection hasn’t changed since 2021, and that the Port Elizabeth claim was the first he’d heard of it. Even some of Khawaja’s supporters have questions. Chad Sayers, who was also in that squad, told Channel 7, quote, “Everything Usman says in his article is accurate.” Quote. But he also asked, “If he felt so strongly about it, why didn’t he say something at the time?”
And then this week, the story got wider. Stuart MacGill, who played 44 tests for Australia as a leg spinner, admitted on a Fanatics TV YouTube show that he had used sandpaper himself during his career. Remember Khawaja’s line about the umpire dropping the ball on the boundary? Here’s MacGill describing his method. The umpires would leave the ball just over the boundary. He’d tape, quote, “A little bit of square of sandpaper to his thumb,” pick the ball up, quote, “scratch the living daylights out of it,” then, quote, “chuck it in the gutter before a ball had even been bowled.” He says it wasn’t part of a, quote, “massive global cheating scam,” and his justification is revealing. Quote, “Because we know that everybody’s doing it, it doesn’t feel so bad.” None of that proves what happened in 2018, but it does make it much harder to argue that the method Khawaja describes is far-fetched.
Which brings us to Cricket Australia. Khawaja says that back in 2021, after Bancroft’s interview, he tried again to push for collective responsibility. He says he contacted Justin Langer, who was coach by then, and the chief executive of the Players Association, that was Todd Greenberg, and he says the bowler’s statement ended that effort. Todd Greenberg is now the chief executive of Cricket Australia. He’s the one saying the investigation stays closed.
Cricket Australia’s statement says, quote, “All relevant information presented to Cricket Australia to date has been properly considered.” Unquote. And Greenberg has gone further. Quote, “We don’t see any compelling reason to open the investigation or revisit it again.” He says there’s, quote, “Absolutely no benefit in going back.”
To be fair to Greenberg, his position isn’t unreasonable on its face. He wasn’t at Cricket Australia in 2018. Nobody on the current board or executive actually was. He says he’s spoken to many of the players involved over the past few days, and their position hasn’t changed. His argument is that a new investigation just ends up in the same place, one person’s version against another’s, eight years later.
But there are two problems with that. The first is, some of this is genuinely new. Port Elizabeth is a separate allegation about a separate test. The original investigation wasn’t looking at it at all. A player who sat beside Bancroft says he was never asked a single question, and another squad member has backed this account. So whatever you make of it, that’s not the same evidence that Cricket Australia had in 2018.
The second is that Greenberg says the board’s comfort with the outcome includes what it’s seen from Khawaja, but he’s also said he hasn’t read the book yet. He’s read the coverage and he’s spoken to Khawaja, but it’s still a difficult thing to be, quote, “comfortable with information you haven’t fully reviewed.”
So why would a board take this position? Because the people at the center of the unanswered question have not retired. They’re the core of the current test team. Cummins is the captain. Starc, Hazlewood, and Lyon are still in the side. Australia start a four-test home series against New Zealand on December the 9th. Reopening the investigation means investigating your own captain and team leaders in the middle of your home summer.
And look at what else is coming. Australia have just lost 2-1 in South Africa. Marnus Labuschagne has been dropped, and after New Zealand, there’s a five-test tour of India, the 150th anniversary test against England in Melbourne in March, and an away Ashes next June and July. Michael Atherton says there are already, quote, “cracks in that team.”
Cricket Australia also remembers exactly what this story cost it the first time. For a governing body, a closed file is a lot easier than an open file. But closed only works if people let it stay closed, and right now, they’re not.
Michael Vaughan, writing in The Telegraph, says, quote, “It has been an open secret in cricket circles.” And he goes further. Quote, “Cricket Australia is as culpable as any of the players involved.” Hussain, another former England captain, calls the whole thing, quote, “a complete mess.” He can’t understand how nobody in a meeting said, quote, “I don’t think this is okay.” And he’s blunt about the investigation. Quote, “For Cricket Australia not to speak to every player, not to speak to Khawaja, who was sitting next to Bancroft, it just feels like a right mess.” For a team built on the baggy green and mateship, he says, quote… It was never going to be just those three.
Michael Clarke wants it reopened. He says Australian fans, quote, “Can’t trust what’s real.” And he’s asked why we haven’t heard from Cummins, pointing out that Cummins would never have become captain without Cape Town. Peter Collins, who led a review after the scandal, has reportedly called for it to be reopened too.
On the other side, the Players Association says Smith, Warner, and Bancroft already paid a disproportionate price, and it wants the vitriol to stop. Mark Taylor says, quote, “I’m disappointed we’re going to keep asking it again and again.” Alyssa Healy, who is married to Mitchell Starc, says the timing is, quote, “A little bit sticky.” And Cummins, before the details came out, said simply, quote, “As a group, we have moved on.”
And then there’s Michael Atherton, who might be the most interesting voice of all. He doesn’t think a new investigation is needed, but he calls Cricket Australia’s original handling, quote, “The worst of both worlds.” In his world, quote, “They handed down unbelievably heavy sanctions and left three players to take the rap, but it left questions unanswered, left the door open for it to come back to haunt them, which is what it is doing right now.” And he thinks the thing really bothering the Australian fans isn’t the sandpaper, it’s the sense of players, quote, “Not having people’s backs.”
That split is the story. This isn’t a fringe pile-on. Serious people with serious reasons are on both sides, which is exactly what our poll is showing.
So what happens next? The player everyone is waiting on is Pat Cummins. Greenberg says the captain will speak in the coming days or weeks. Mitch Marsh, who played in all four tests of that series but didn’t sign the 2021 statement, is leading the white ball side against England, so questions will follow him too. But it’s Cummins whose answers really matter. That’s where this really turns. If Cummins repeats the 2021 statement, Cricket Australia’s position holds, at least for now. If anything he says leaves room for any doubt, quote, “No compelling reason,” becomes very hard to defend.
So here’s our take. Cricket Australia may well be right that a second investigation wouldn’t produce a neat, clean answer, but that really isn’t the test or the point. The test is whether the first one asked everyone it should have asked, and on Khawaja’s account, it didn’t. And until Cricket Australia explains why, this chapter doesn’t close just because the board wants it to. Which side of the 50/50 split are you on? Let us know in the comments.