Cricket Australia has acknowledged that the competing accounts of the 2018 Sandpapergate scandal may never be reconciled without further evidence, as former Australia fast bowler Chadd Sayers has provided new details about the ball-tampering operation and challenged the version of events maintained by current Test Captain Pat Cummins.
The governing body’s latest statement follows a series of allegations about the use of sandpaper during Australia’s tour of South Africa, the extent of players’ knowledge and the investigation that ultimately punished only three cricketers. With David Warner questioning the fairness of that process and former players offering sharply different assessments, the controversy has again become a significant issue for Australian cricket’s leadership and credibility.
Sayers challenges Australia’s account of the scandal
Sayers, who was part of Australia’s squad during the 2018 South Africa tour and served as 12th man in Cape Town, has emerged as a central figure in the renewed controversy. His account supports former opener Usman Khawaja’s contention that awareness of the ball-tampering operation extended beyond the three players sanctioned by Cricket Australia.
Speaking on SEN Cricket, Sayers maintained that he was not aligning himself with either Khawaja or Cummins, both of whom he had played alongside. He nevertheless challenged the suggestion that knowledge of the operation was restricted to a small group, saying: “There are no sides; they’ve both been great to me throughout my time in the Test squad, so I’m not taking sides. I’m neutral in all this. I’m comfortable sitting here right now and where I stand on the situation that I believe that everyone in that side knew what was going on and what was being used.”
View this post on Instagram
His account also extends the allegations beyond the third Test at Newlands, where Cameron Bancroft was caught on camera attempting to alter the condition of the ball. Sayers alleged that sandpaper had already been used in the preceding Test at Port Elizabeth and that the subject had been discussed within the Australian dressing room.
He described those earlier conversations while acknowledging the limitations of recalling events eight years later: “In Port Elizabeth, so as it’s known now, it was used in two Test matches, and there were discussions in the change rooms of how we were going to get the ball to reverse and what was going to be used. I mean, it is eight years ago, so my recollection isn’t as clear as it was obviously eight years ago. I just know that there was numerous conversations of it around in the change rooms.”
Sayers further alleged that Bancroft volunteered to carry out the plan because Warner was attracting considerable attention at the time. He also described personally removing the sandpaper from the field while delivering drinks during the Cape Town Test, an account that places him directly within the sequence of events surrounding the incident.
Explaining his involvement, Sayers recalled: “(The sandpaper) was given to me to take off. I was just the player who took the drinks out at the time. (I came) on to the field with drinks and, yeah, it was passed on to me.”
Sayers subsequently made his only Test appearance for Australia in the fourth match of the series, in Johannesburg.
Cricket Australia acknowledges conflicting accounts
In a statement addressing the renewed allegations, a Cricket Australia spokesperson said: “We respect the right of those in South Africa in 2018 to share their version of what they believe happened on that tour.”
The governing body also acknowledged the gulf between the competing recollections, adding: “The significant differences in the views expressed continues to demonstrate that it is very unlikely an agreed version of events will be reached without relevant material evidence.”
The statement comes amid continuing disagreement over both the original ball-tampering operation and the internal response after Bancroft was caught. Sayers has described a dressing-room discussion lasting approximately 60 to 90 minutes after the incident, during which the players considered what had happened and how to proceed.
He also said he remained near the team hotel in anticipation of interviews during Cricket Australia’s investigation but was never questioned. Sayers suggested his status as 12th man might explain the omission, although he did not claim to know why investigators had not approached him.
Warner raises new questions about the investigation
Warner, who received a 12-month suspension following the scandal, has become one of the strongest critics of Cricket Australia’s original inquiry. He has supported Khawaja’s account and questioned whether investigators established the full extent of the touring party’s knowledge before determining responsibility.
In an Instagram post, Warner raised doubts about whether bowlers Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc and Nathan Lyon had been interviewed. He argued that the investigation appeared to have concentrated responsibility on a predetermined group of players and concluded: “That stinks of a cover-up.”
View this post on Instagram
That allegation has since encountered contradictory information. Sources connected to Australia’s bowling group told the ABC that Starc, Hazlewood and Lyon had been interviewed, while Cummins has publicly confirmed speaking to investigators. The ABC also reported that former Australia Captain Tim Paine was questioned.
Warner subsequently clarified that his criticism concerned the information made available to him during the original process, rather than a definitive assertion that the bowlers had never been interviewed.
In a follow-up Instagram post, he wrote: “I was never told the bowlers had been interviewed or provided statements.”
View this post on Instagram
Warner then questioned the evidence available to the sanctioned players when decisions were being made in 2018, adding: “That information would’ve been pretty useful when I was forced to make decisions back in 2018. Why weren’t we given all the evidence by CA?”
Cricket Australia has maintained that players were given opportunities to contribute to the original investigation and could subsequently provide additional evidence.
The initial inquiry resulted in 12-month bans for Warner and then-Captain Steve Smith, while Bancroft received a nine-month suspension. Warner also lost his eligibility for future Australian team leadership under the sanctions imposed at the time.
Khawaja’s autobiography reignites the dispute
The latest controversy began with the publication of Khawaja’s autobiography, _Sabr_, in which he challenged the established account of who knew about the sandpaper operation.
The former Australia opener told The Sydney Morning Herald: “It was all of us. Not the batters, not the bowlers, not the staff. All of us.”
Khawaja has also maintained that he was not interviewed during Cricket Australia’s investigation despite being present for discussions about the ball. He has said his decision to share his account followed a promise to Warner that he would eventually describe what happened from his perspective.
The allegations have drawn particular attention because Australia’s four specialist bowlers from the Cape Town Test — Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Lyon — issued a joint statement in 2021 denying knowledge that a foreign substance had been taken onto the field to alter the ball.
Starc has reiterated that his recollection remains consistent with that statement. The disagreement is therefore not simply about the sanctions imposed in 2018, but about conflicting accounts from players who were members of the same touring squad.
Cummins rejects allegations as scrutiny intensifies
Cummins addressed the renewed controversy during a lengthy press conference, rejecting Khawaja’s suggestion that he and other players had been involved in planning the use of sandpaper.
The Australia Test and ODI Captain told reporters: “He says that I and others were architects of a scheme to ball tamper with sandpaper. That’s complete and utter nonsense.”
Cummins also criticised the effect of Khawaja’s allegations on the reputations of former teammates. Sayers, meanwhile, expressed discomfort with the personal nature of the Captain’s response, although he maintained that he was not taking sides in the disagreement.
Warner has publicly backed Khawaja and criticised Cummins’ treatment of his former opening partner. The confrontation has added another dimension to a dispute already involving questions about the investigation and the responsibilities of the players who escaped punishment.
Todd Greenberg rules out reopening the inquiry
Despite the additional accounts, Cricket Australia Chief Executive Todd Greenberg has rejected calls for a fresh investigation.
Speaking to SEN, Greenberg said the governing body remained satisfied with the outcome of the original process, including its assessment of the material emerging from Khawaja’s autobiography.
He stated: “We don’t see any compelling reason to open the investigation or revisit this again. I don’t think there’s anything that can be gained from that.”
Greenberg has also pointed to the differing recollections of former teammates and the consistency of the denials made by several players since 2018. Cricket Australia’s position is that the latest public allegations have not provided sufficient grounds to revisit the decisions made under its previous leadership.
That stance has come under renewed attention following comments from Dr Simon Longstaff, the ethics expert commissioned to examine Australian cricket’s culture after the scandal.
Longstaff said he had heard suggestions during his review that ball-tampering might have occurred before Cape Town and that more people could have known about it. Speaking to Nine’s Weekend Today, he recalled: “Along the way, there were whispers, and I can’t put it any more strongly than that, that something else had gone on earlier and that more people had known.”
He explained that senior figures had been given opportunities to disclose additional information, but nobody amended their account. Longstaff said he had not obtained sufficient evidence at the time to recommend another inquiry. He has also expressed belief in the sincerity of Cummins’ denial, while distinguishing that from the wider question of whether other individuals knew about the operation.
Former players divide over responsibility and accountability
The dispute has prompted contrasting reactions from former international cricketers, particularly over whether Australia’s bowlers could realistically have been unaware of changes made to the ball for their benefit.
Former India spinner Murali Kartik questioned that possibility during a discussion on Cricbuzz, arguing that a plan designed to produce reverse swing would ordinarily require cooperation from the bowlers using the ball.
Kartik said: “I was surprised that only three guys had to bear the brunt of it. Everybody, all the bowlers, would’ve known. When you’re trying to do something for the sake of the bowlers, wouldn’t you tell the bowlers? How can anyone believe that? Are we in kindergarten to accept that sort of thing? There have been so many murmurs: ‘Oh, Warner is going to come out with a tell-all. Warner is going to tell the story once he is done with everything.’ It’s not him, it’s Usman Khawaja who has come out and said that everybody knew. I am pretty sure everybody knew. They are all trying to stay on the same page.”
Former Pakistan Captain Wasim Akram offered a more cautious assessment. He acknowledged Cummins’ denial and suggested it was possible the wider team had not known what was happening. However, Akram also drew on his experience as a fast bowler to explain why sandpaper would leave recognisable marks on the ball.
In a video posted on Instagram, Akram observed: “But the sandpaper scratch is totally different from the one-bounce scratch. And as a cricket lover, if you want to check, grab a semi-new cricket ball, grab a sandpaper, and rub it in, you know, the scratches are totally different.”
View this post on Instagram
Former South Africa Captain AB de Villiers has similarly distinguished the legitimate pursuit of reverse swing from prohibited methods of changing the ball’s condition. He also recalled how South Africa handled its own ball-tampering controversy involving Faf du Plessis, when the wider squad publicly supported its Captain rather than treating the issue solely as an individual responsibility.
Clarke defends Khawaja as Watson questions his role
Beyond the disagreement over what happened in South Africa, Khawaja has faced questions about why he chose to revisit the scandal in an autobiography.
Former Australia Captain Michael Clarke has defended him against suggestions that the revelations were primarily intended to generate book sales. Drawing on his experience of publishing an autobiography, Clarke explained that players generally receive an agreed payment and only become eligible for additional incentives once sales reach certain thresholds.
Speaking on the Beyond 23 Podcast, Clarke said: “Usman did this book three years ago, he knew how much money he was going to get. No matter what he put in it, that money doesn’t change. Yes you get paid for a book, you aren’t writing a book for free…I don’t think he has done this for money.”
View this post on Instagram
Khawaja has also rejected the financial-motivation argument, saying he does not expect substantial royalties from the publication.
Former Australia all-rounder Shane Watson has raised a different issue, questioning why Khawaja rather than one of the three sanctioned players chose to bring the controversy back into public debate. Watson suggested that the suspensions might have created additional selection opportunities for Khawaja during a period when his place in Australia’s Test side was not secure.
Speaking on Prime Video’s _In the Middle with Watto_, Watson said: “In the end, he did benefit. I know he probably won’t look at it that way, but he did benefit from those three guys having a long ban.”
View this post on Instagram
Watson nevertheless acknowledged Khawaja’s subsequent career resurgence, which saw him return to the Test side and establish himself as a regular before retiring in 2026.
Australian cricket faces calls to move forward
Other prominent former players have focused on the consequences of prolonging the public dispute.
Former Australia Head Coach Justin Langer supported Cummins’ decision to address the allegations directly, while expressing concern about the impact of the controversy on players, supporters and the wider Australian cricket community.
Former Australia Captain Greg Chappell also urged the parties to move forward. Drawing on his own experience of the 1981 underarm bowling controversy, Chappell argued that mistakes and their consequences can remain part of cricket’s history for decades, but should not prevent the sport from focusing on the future.
Those appeals have not resolved the central disagreement. Sayers’ account has added new testimony from within the 2018 touring party, while Warner continues to challenge the transparency of the original investigation and Australia’s bowlers maintain their longstanding denials.
For Cricket Australia, the immediate position remains unchanged: Greenberg has ruled out reopening the inquiry, and the governing body has acknowledged that a shared account of Sandpapergate is unlikely to emerge without relevant material evidence.