Cricket Australia (CA) has moved to halt more than a week of escalating fallout over the 2018 ball-tampering scandal, announcing an independent and confidential forum that will allow players and staff from the South Africa tour to give their accounts of what happened in Cape Town, and in the lead-up to it, eight and a half years on.
Chief Executive Todd Greenberg and interim Chair David Boon unveiled the process at a hastily called press conference at Bellerive Oval in Hobart on Wednesday afternoon, roughly an hour before Australia’s third ODI against England. The board had met the previous evening to sign off on the decision.
“After careful consideration, the CA Board has decided to establish a forum that will allow players and staff involved in the events of South Africa in 2018 to share their experiences and perspectives,” said Boon. “We believe this is in the best interests of the game. For almost a decade, the fallout from those events has remained part of the conversation around Australian cricket.
“It has been a difficult chapter for many people and, increasingly, the ongoing debate has become a distraction from the game. We believe it is time for a circuit breaker.”
The announcement marks a significant shift in CA’s position. Only days earlier, Greenberg had ruled out reopening the original investigation, telling SEN: “We don’t see any compelling reason to open the investigation or revisit this again.” That investigation still will not be reopened, but the governing body has now accepted that the story cannot be closed without giving those involved a formal channel to be heard.
How the forum will work
Participation is entirely voluntary, and the sessions will be held in confidence. An independent figure, most likely a King’s Counsel or a former judge, is expected to be appointed in the coming days, with terms of reference to follow. For now, the forum is open only to the players and staff who were part of the 2018 touring party.
What the public eventually learns is a matter for the CA board once the process concludes. Greenberg said he expects the forum to take about a month, although it will not be finished before Australia’s first Test against New Zealand. “We will look to be as transparent as we possibly can, whilst at the same time protecting the confidentiality of the people who come forward,” he said.
Boon was clear that the board does not see the process as a retrial. “This forum is not about relitigating the past. It is about creating an opportunity for those who wish to be heard to tell their stories in a respectful environment, and for our sport to listen,” he said. “Australian cricket is at its strongest when it is united. We owe it to everyone who loves the game to make every reasonable effort to move forward together, with understanding, respect and perspective.”
Greenberg reinforced that message, saying CA would need to keep an open mind about how it handles what emerges. “As part of this process, and so that all parties who wish to can tell their version of events, we have set up now an independent forum,” he said. “It’s a chance to give everyone a voice in an independent and a safe setting. It’s not a re-investigation. It’s not designed to re-prosecute or to sanction.
“No one is compelled to participate. It is entirely up to each individual. It’s important to remember we’re talking about events that happened eight and a half years ago, and I hope everyone will respect this process.”
“Not a reinvestigation”
Greenberg confirmed that the original 2018 report will not be released, citing confidentiality. He also confirmed that he has read it, and that only eight of the 11 players who appeared in the Cape Town Test were interviewed, along with a group of coaches and support staff. That admission goes to the heart of one of Khawaja’s central complaints: that he was never questioned, despite sitting next to Cameron Bancroft in the dressing room throughout the Test.
Greenberg acknowledged that the 2018 inquiry, which examined the use of sandpaper in Cape Town but not in earlier Tests, was carried out quickly given the short turnaround before the fourth Test in Johannesburg. “I’ve spent a lot of time reading through the reports and the investigation. Eight of the 11 players who played that Test match were interviewed. A number of staff were interviewed,” he said. “People can be critical of what happened there. We won’t do that because I think that’s unfair and unjust, and it’s hard to look through the prism of hindsight.”
He said the forum was intended for those who felt shut out the first time. “The forum is designed where people who weren’t interviewed or weren’t offered the opportunity or didn’t feel like they had the opportunity to contribute to now contribute. We want to be able to give them the opportunity that they deserve.”
Pressed on why the forum stops short of a fresh inquiry, Greenberg said the challenge was not a lack of testimony but its inconsistency. “The investigation was complete. What we’re trying to do is give people an opportunity to complete their version of events,” he said. “We’ve got almost everyone’s version of events, and they differ markedly. This is the greatest challenge with this project. People’s version of events at the time differ substantially, and we have to give enormous respect for each individual, whether that’s different to someone else’s.
“That’s understandable, but this is not a reinvestigation, it’s providing the opportunity for those people to speak. Someone’s version of events will contradict someone else’s version of events.”
He also had a message for anyone who comes forward. “Anyone who comes in to this forum to provide their views, I would encourage them to be as specific as possible. It’s hard to deal with generalities.”
That echoes CA’s position earlier in the week, when a spokesperson conceded the competing accounts may never be reconciled, saying “it is very unlikely an agreed version of events will be reached without relevant material evidence.”
Asked whether the process was designed to clear current Test captain Pat Cummins, who has publicly rejected Khawaja’s claims, Greenberg was emphatic. “The captain doesn’t need to be cleared. No one’s looking to be cleared.”
Nor, he said, was it intended to placate the two former players driving the debate. Asked whether the forum would appease Warner and Khawaja in particular, he said: “I don’t know, and this is not about appeasing any individual. This is about the game. It’s about the sport.”
“The game is genuinely hurting”
Most striking was Greenberg’s candour about the damage the past week has done. “The game is genuinely hurting at the moment,” he said. “It’s not good for anyone. We need to find a path through, and we need some time to heal.”
“Over the last week, I think the game has suffered enormously,” he said. “I’ve said before, I think the game’s really hurting at the moment and there are relationships and friendships from players that have shared dressing rooms for decades that are under enormous strain.
“It’s incumbent on us to try to find a path for that. Let’s try to come out the other side. The game is bigger than all of us. We all love cricket.”
He framed the forum as a necessary step rather than a final answer. “The game needs to move on somehow. These events are eight years ago. They cause enormous pain and hurt for lots of people, and they’re doing it again now,” he said. “At some point, we have to move forward and we can’t move forward without putting some of these steps in place.”
Greenberg also went further than CA has previously gone in accepting the governing body’s share of responsibility. The cultural review that followed the scandal, conducted by The Ethics Centre, found a “win at all costs” mentality had taken hold in the men’s team. Cummins has since admitted the side had an “ugly underbelly” that he set out to remove as captain.
“What happened then and continues to play out now has a lot to do with the culture that existed at that time. A culture that CA played a part in creating,” Greenberg said. “The recognition of that came through the commissioning of the Ethics Centre report and subsequent adoption of 36 of the 42 recommendations.
“We are indeed proud of the culture that the team has built over the past eight years. Our players and our leaders and our coaches deserve enormous credit for that, in particular Pat and Andrew \[McDonald, Head Coach\], who lead this team with distinction. But we recognise the pain and hurt that events surrounding Sandpapergate have caused.”
Khawaja and Warner: “what comes out at the end?”
The two men at the centre of the dispute welcomed the forum, with reservations. Speaking on Kayo Sports immediately after the announcement, Khawaja said: “I applaud CA for doing this. I wish they did a little bit earlier. But there’s still some questions to be had, which I’m sure I’ll talk to Todd about in the next week. We all want to move on. The question is, will this allow us to move on? That’s the question that has to be asked.”
He added: “I have always wanted a safe space to chat. I also have some questions about Cricket Australia because the public want to know what happened there. It’s hard to get the whole truth unless everyone is speaking.”
His concern was less about the forum itself than what the board will do with it. “I don’t think there should be any sanctions. The board makes the decisions, but what comes out at the end?” he said. “I have a really good relationship with Todd Greenberg, and I respect what he’s trying to do there. But at the end of the day, if you’re going to cherry-pick what is said in this report, the board can choose whatever they want to come in, or come out. Are we just going in a circle here? That’s the thing I’m not sure about.”
Warner, speaking alongside him, also ruled out any appetite for further penalties. “We put our hands up, we accepted what Cricket Australia handed out to us. It’s not about penalties,” he said. “It’s about transparency and accountability, which Todd’s acknowledged, on CA’s behalf, about the culture at the time with the players and CA.”
How the week unravelled
The forum is the product of a remarkably fast-moving crisis. Khawaja’s autobiography _Sabr_, published last week, alleged that sandpaper had already been used in the preceding Test in Port Elizabeth, that knowledge extended well beyond Steve Smith, Warner and Bancroft, and that a 70-minute meeting took place in the Cape Town rooms after the incident at which collective responsibility was discussed. In the book’s wake, Khawaja told _The Sydney Morning Herald_: “It was all of us. Not the batters, not the bowlers, not the staff. All of us.”
Smith and Warner received 12-month bans in 2018, and Bancroft nine months. Warner was also handed a lifetime leadership ban, since revoked. Warner quickly backed Khawaja’s account in a video message, saying: “It’s 100 per cent accurate what you’ve said. Now everyone knows the truth. It’s out there.”
Pressure on CA mounted from multiple directions. Peter Collins, who worked on the governing body’s post-scandal cultural review, called for a fresh independent inquiry, warning: “Cricket Australia cannot just hope it all goes away. Failing to investigate won’t resolve the issue.” A _Sydney Morning Herald_ report, citing tour sources, identified former bowling coach David Saker as the unnamed coach referred to in Khawaja’s account. Khawaja does not name the coach himself. According to those sources, Saker urged Smith and Bancroft to conceal the use of sandpaper before the Cape Town press conference, allegedly telling them: “You can’t say sandpaper.” Saker left CA in February 2019, and tour sources believe he signed a non-disclosure agreement, although its terms have not been established. He did not respond to a request for comment. In a 2021 interview with the _Herald_, he had said: “There was a lot of people to blame. It could have been me to blame, it could have been someone else.”
Former Test spinner Stuart MacGill then admitted using sandpaper to alter the ball during his own career, which ended in 2008. “I’d cut a small piece of sandpaper and tape it to my thumb,” he said on the FanaticsTV YouTube show, adding: “And because we know that everybody’s doing it, it doesn’t feel so bad.” His admission predates Cape Town and does not establish what anyone in the 2018 squad knew.
The current leadership group pushed back hard. Cummins, in a 68-minute press conference in Sydney last Friday, called the allegations “complete and utter nonsense”. “When he says we all knew, if by that he means that we knew sandpaper was going out in the field, he’s 100% wrong,” he said, adding: “Usman’s a friend, but friends aren’t casual with each other’s lives and reputations.” Warner responded on Fox Cricket that “the captain today actually threw Uzzy under the bus.”
Mitchell Starc maintained the bowlers’ 2021 joint denial, saying: “We weren’t aware of anything taken on the field to be tampered with. We saw it on the big screen in Cape Town.” Boon himself told _The Australian_ during the week: “We absolutely support Pat.”
Then came Chadd Sayers, the 12th man in Cape Town, who made his Test debut in the following match in Johannesburg. He backed Khawaja’s version, saying he was aware of sandpaper use in Port Elizabeth and that he was the one who carried it off the field after Bancroft used it. “I believe that everyone in that side knew what was going on and what was being used,” he said, while insisting: “I’m not taking sides. I’m neutral in all this.” He also said he was never questioned by investigators.
The players’ body chose not to adjudicate. Australian Cricketers’ Association Chief Executive Paul Marsh said the ACA would not comment on individual accounts, adding: “Eight years on, it is understandable that those involved may have different recollections and perspectives.” And with his manager confirming he was assessing whether to put something out, Bancroft himself has been weighing whether to break years of public silence.
A test of trust for CA
The decision lands on an industry that is itself divided. A cricexec poll of global cricket executives found a perfect 50-50 split on whether CA should reopen its 2018 investigation. The forum is CA’s attempt to find ground between the two camps.
Whether it succeeds will depend on two things CA cannot fully control: who chooses to take part, and whether the board’s eventual disclosure is seen as credible. Greenberg’s admission that three of the 11 Cape Town players were never interviewed gives the forum a clear gap to fill. Khawaja’s warning about “cherry-picking” signals precisely where it will be judged.
Former coach Darren Lehmann summed up the uncertainty. “We’ve got to try move forward for Australian cricket, but how that happens I don’t know… your guess is as good as mine,” he said.
For now, CA has chosen a process over a verdict. Its credibility will rest on what it is prepared to make public when the forum concludes.
