Cricket Australia’s independent forum on the 2018 ball-tampering scandal was only hours old when it was handed the most consequential testimony it is ever likely to receive, and not in confidence.
On Wednesday, hours after Chief Executive Todd Greenberg and interim Chair David Boon announced the voluntary, confidential process at Bellerive Oval, Cameron Bancroft published a first-person account of the scandal in _The West Australian_. Running to roughly 4,000 words, it is the first time in eight and a half years that the player caught with sandpaper in Cape Town has given his own detailed version of events.
Its central admission goes to the heart of CA’s position. “When I was questioned during Cricket Australia’s investigation, I did not give a complete and truthful account,” Bancroft wrote. “I withheld important details, including when the use of sandpaper began, how long it went on for, and the involvement and awareness of others. I did this to protect Cricket Australia’s investigation and not implicate others around me.”
His conclusion is blunt. “It was not just the three of us — Steve Smith, David Warner and I — who knew about me using sandpaper on the ball in South Africa,” he wrote. “It was the whole team.”
The response from the current captain was swift and brief. In a statement released through his representatives, CODE Sports, Pat Cummins’ camp said: “Whilst we feel for Cam and everything he’s been through, there’s nothing in the statement that hasn’t been answered by Pat in his press conference.”
CA, for its part, said in a statement: “We respect that Cameron Bancroft has told his story, and we will take time to consider his comments. We expect that there will be many dimensions to the events of 2018, which is why we have established the forum for individuals to give their version of events. We are finalising the terms of reference and will commence the process as soon as possible.”
An investigation built on incomplete testimony
For the governing body, the significance of Bancroft’s piece lies less in any single allegation than in what it says about the foundations of the 2018 process.
At Wednesday’s press conference, Greenberg had been firm that the original investigation would not be reopened. “The investigation was complete,” he said. He confirmed that eight of the 11 players who appeared in the Cape Town Test were interviewed, acknowledged the inquiry had been conducted quickly ahead of the fourth Test in Johannesburg, and said the challenge now was that accounts “differ markedly.”
Bancroft’s admission adds a further complication: one of the three players CA sanctioned now says the account he gave investigators at the time was itself incomplete. By his own telling, the scope of the inquiry, which focused on Cape Town rather than earlier Tests, also missed where the practice began.
He framed his decision to go public as consistent with, not in opposition to, the forum. “I appreciate Todd’s comments and the chance for players and staff to have an opportunity to speak,” he wrote. “Transparency is a way to acknowledge our respect for cricket, a game we love and something that is bigger than all of us. And that is why I will attend the forum. But it’s also why the public need to know my story today.”
He also echoed the request Greenberg made on Wednesday, when the Chief Executive urged anyone coming forward to “be as specific as possible”, adding: “It’s hard to deal with generalities.” Bancroft wrote that he was looking forward to being part of the forum and to speaking “as specific and detailed as possible without being general.”
A culture that predated South Africa
Bancroft’s account begins not in South Africa but in the 2017-18 Ashes, his first Test series. He describes an environment in which ball maintenance was a routine topic of team conversation and David Warner was the side’s acknowledged expert on reverse swing.
He recalls being instructed, along with other players, to press the ball’s quarter seam together after wickets fell. “It was something the group was directed to do, and as a young player entering the Australian team, I accepted it as part of how we operated,” he wrote. “We were ruthless and willing to do these sorts of behaviours and cross boundaries to give ourselves an advantage, to win.”
According to Bancroft, sandpaper was not used in the first Test of the South Africa series in Durban, where he was not responsible for the ball. What followed in Port Elizabeth, he wrote, “was a significant escalation. And it was where I became directly involved.”
That context aligns with the “win at all costs” mentality identified by The Ethics Centre’s cultural review after the scandal, and with Greenberg’s acknowledgement on Wednesday that it was “a culture that CA played a part in creating.”
Port Elizabeth: “where the sandpaper began”
Bancroft places the start of the sandpaper use at the tea break on day two of the second Test at St George’s Park, with South Africa on 2/153 and Australia struggling to move the ball.
He describes a dressing-room conversation about generating reverse swing in which, he says, bowling coach David Saker was involved and Head Coach Darren Lehmann was present, with other players moving in and out. It was in that setting, Bancroft wrote, that Warner raised the possibility of using sandpaper, explaining that he could not do it himself because television cameras were following him so closely.
“I don’t believe Dave was acting purely for himself,” Bancroft wrote. “I understood his suggestion as an attempt to help the team regain control of the match. That doesn’t excuse his involvement or mine.”
He recalls people in the room agreeing, but also that Captain Steve Smith “made it clear that he wanted no part in it before distancing himself”, and that others warned him to be careful or said they would not do it in his position. “I knew it was wrong,” he wrote. “I knew that using sandpaper was not simply pushing the boundaries of the laws of cricket. It was cheating.”
He attributes his decision to inexperience and a desire to belong. “I was a youngster playing in his seventh Test match. If you asked me to run through a brick wall at that time I would have,” he wrote. “That desire to belong clouded my judgement. I agreed.”
Bancroft says he used sandpaper on the ball as the team walked out after tea, exploiting a window before broadcast cameras picked up the fielders, and continued to use it nearly every over for the rest of that session and the remainder of the Test.
The most contentious section concerns the bowlers. Bancroft says he regularly sought feedback from the fast bowlers — naming Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh — and from wicketkeeper Tim Paine on whether the ball was reversing. “Is it going yet? It’s not going yet, it needs more. So I would use the sandpaper more on the ball,” he wrote, adding that at one stage he was told to stop because it was becoming too obvious.
Australia took 4/28 in that session. Bancroft recalls teammates praising him — “Great work Bang. Keep it up” — alongside warnings to “be careful”, and Smith saying, “I don’t want to know about it.”
He also describes a team meeting on the morning of day three at which, he says, his use of sandpaper the previous evening was discussed and his role acknowledged in front of the group, with encouragement from playing and coaching staff, “especially David Saker.”
In the same meeting, he says, one person objected. Bancroft recalls team media manager Kate Hutchison making clear she believed it was wrong and wanted nothing to do with it. “I will never forget that. Somebody had spoken up,” he wrote, while noting: “I cannot speak for Kate’s thoughts beyond what I remember her saying and doing. She deserves the opportunity to give her own account.”
“We did. I did. And I chose to continue,” he wrote of the chance to question what was happening. South Africa went on to win the Test.
Cape Town and the press conference
At Newlands, Bancroft says, he sat beside Usman Khawaja and Paine in the smaller of the two change rooms. He confirms Khawaja’s account that a coach approached him during Australia’s fielding innings urging him to do more with the sandpaper. “That coach was David Saker and it is true,” he wrote.
He says the same on-field conversations with the bowlers continued, though the sandpaper was less effective in damp, green conditions. Then came the moment he was caught on camera. Bancroft says Peter Handscomb ran out at the drinks break to take the sandpaper from him after “Boof” — Lehmann’s nickname — called down the walkie-talkie for it to be removed. “In my opinion, if he didn’t know he wouldn’t have said that,” Bancroft wrote. “Once again. WE ALL KNEW.”
Lehmann has previously said he did not know about the plan beforehand. Saker, who left CA in February 2019, did not respond when the _Sydney Morning Herald_ sought comment last week on reports, citing tour sources, that identified him as the unnamed coach in Khawaja’s book.
Bancroft’s account of the press conference that followed is among its most damaging passages for the team’s management. He says Saker specifically warned against naming sandpaper as the material used, and that others agreed. “We cannot say we used sandpaper,” he recalls being told. Bancroft and Smith instead described tape and material collected from the ground. “It was another lie,” he wrote. “One told while we were supposedly taking responsibility.”
After the Test, Bancroft describes a lengthy meeting of players and staff, corroborating the meeting both Khawaja and Chadd Sayers have described. “Nobody in that meeting stood up and said they had been completely unaware of my use of sandpaper. Not one person,” he wrote. “As it turns out I ended up becoming the scapegoat for the entire team.”
The bowlers and the captain
Bancroft’s piece is, in large part, a response to Cummins. He wrote that the captain’s 68-minute press conference in Sydney last Friday was “the final straw”, and that it left him feeling “angry, betrayed and alone.”
“What I saw, experienced and lived with – not only him, but everyone else on that tour in South Africa – is not the public account he gave in his press conference and in the years previously when he has spoken on this time,” he wrote.
At that press conference, Cummins called Khawaja’s claims “complete and utter nonsense”, adding: “When he says we all knew, if by that he means that we knew sandpaper was going out in the field, he’s 100% wrong.” He said he had no recollection of any conversation about collective responsibility, and described Khawaja as “a friend, but friends aren’t casual with each other’s lives and reputations.”
Bancroft revisits the 2021 interview with _The Guardian_ in which he described the bowlers’ awareness as “self-explanatory”, prompting Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon to issue a joint statement denying they knew a foreign substance had been taken onto the field. “Reading that statement was deeply painful,” he wrote.
Notably, Bancroft draws a distinction that goes to the heart of the dispute. “I recognise there is a distinction between knowing a ball is reversing, suspecting it has been altered and knowing specifically that sandpaper has been used,” he wrote. His account, however, is that his teammates “knew I wasn’t just plucking at the quarter seam, but that I was actually using sandpaper.”
Marsh, whom Bancroft names among the bowlers he consulted, was not a signatory to the 2021 statement and last week declined to share his recollections, saying he had “personally moved on.” Bancroft cites Marsh’s silence alongside his own, Khawaja’s and Warner’s, attributing all of them to the same motive: “the want and desire to represent Australia.”
The CODE Sports statement indicates Cummins will not engage further, standing on what he said last Friday. Starc, asked last week whether Bancroft should speak publicly, had replied simply: “go for it.”
The cost of carrying it
The final third of Bancroft’s piece turns to the personal and professional consequences. He has not played a Test since the 2019 Ashes, and writes that his international career “has been destroyed.”
He is careful not to claim he was deliberately excluded, acknowledging that “selection is complicated” and that there were periods when he was out of form. But he points to his record in the Sheffield Shield, saying he has scored the most hundreds of any player in the competition over the past six years. “I would be lying if I said I had never wondered whether the unresolved tension surrounding these events in South Africa had played a part,” he wrote.
After the 2021 interview, he says, he felt increasingly uncomfortable around some of those involved and wondered whether his presence in an Australian dressing room would revive questions others wanted left alone.
“For eight years, I suffered silently. I cannot change the past. But I can change what I do now,” he wrote. “Nobody has pushed me to write this, I don’t feel obliged or to benefit financially by sharing this.”
A forum under immediate pressure
For CA, Bancroft’s intervention reshapes the process it launched on Wednesday before its independent chair has even been appointed.
The board designed the forum as a “circuit breaker”: confidential, voluntary, without sanctions, and explicitly not a reinvestigation. Boon said its purpose was to allow those who wished to be heard to tell their stories “in a respectful environment, and for our sport to listen.” Greenberg said CA would be “as transparent as we possibly can, whilst at the same time protecting the confidentiality of the people who come forward.”
Bancroft has now put a detailed, named account into the public domain before that process begins, including allegations involving former coaching staff and current players. Those named will face pressure to respond publicly, or to explain why they will not. And the board’s eventual decision on what to release from the forum will now be measured against an account the public has already read.
That was precisely the concern Khawaja raised on Kayo Sports on Wednesday, before Bancroft’s piece was published. “If you’re going to cherry-pick what is said in this report, the board can choose whatever they want to come in, or come out,” he said. “Are we just going in a circle here?”
The players’ association has so far declined to adjudicate between competing accounts. Australian Cricketers’ Association Chief Executive Paul Marsh said last week that “players and staff at the heart of the issue are entitled to share their experiences”, while calling for the vitriol directed at those involved to end.
Across the industry, opinion remains evenly divided. A cricexec poll of global cricket executives last week found a 50-50 split on whether CA should reopen its 2018 investigation.
Bancroft closed his piece by quoting Michael Clarke, who said last week that he wanted “whatever the truth is for it all to come out, allow people to finally tell the truth, and move on,” adding: “Fans have not moved on.”
“I do not claim that my account alone settles every question,” Bancroft wrote. “This is my responsibility. And here it is.”
Whether the forum can reconcile his account with those of the teammates who reject it is now the question CA must answer.
