The Benefit of the Doubt: Pat Cummins and Sandpapergate. (Guest Post)

What the latest Sandpapergate revelations do, and don’t, establish. Guest post in cricexec by Vishal Misra. Misra is the RKS Family Professor of Computer Science and Vice Dean for Computing and AI at Columbia Engineering. He is a minority owner of the San Francisco Unicorns and helps lead MaD, the team’s cricket analytics group. The views expressed here are entirely his own and do not represent Columbia University, the San Francisco Unicorns, or Major League Cricket.

Pat Cummins, Usman Khawaja and Cameron Bancroft pictured above a cricket stadium with a red cricket ball and sandpaper in the foreground.

Photo Credit: Facebook Photos of @patcummins30 & @usmankhawaja419, Instagram Photo of @cbancroft4

The latest revelations about Sandpapergate have put Pat Cummins under considerable scrutiny. Usman Khawaja’s book and Cameron Bancroft’s lengthy statement suggest that knowledge of the sandpaper scheme was far more widespread than the original 2018 investigation established. Cummins has denied knowing about the scheme, and some have interpreted his denials as carefully constructed evasions if not outright lies.

I think there’s a perfectly plausible explanation under which Cummins is telling the truth.

A few people have asked me about this because they know I have some connection with Pat. He played a season for the San Francisco Unicorns, we’ve exchanged banter, and have stayed in occasional email contact. I wouldn’t claim we’re (close) friends, but I’ve always found him to be an ethical person and a natural leader.

That doesn’t mean I’ve always agreed with him. In fact, quite the opposite.

When Australia ran out Jonny Bairstow at Lord’s in 2023, I went after Cummins and the Australians relentlessly on Twitter. Dozens of tweets. I thought the dismissal was contrary to the spirit of cricket, particularly given the Australians’ traditional opposition to Mankading on precisely those grounds.

When I first met Pat, I brought up the contradiction. I jokingly offered him a deal: if he would agree that Mankading was legitimate, I would concede that running out Bairstow was legitimate too.

He didn’t hesitate. “Yes, you can quote me on that. Mankading is OK.”

Fair enough. A deal is a deal!

Another incident from the 2024 MLC season hasn’t left me.

Our last league game was against Washington Freedom. The final league positions were already decided and the game was essentially meaningless — they would end up 1st and we’d be 2nd. We would meet them again in the playoffs. Pat wasn’t playing, and Corey Anderson was our captain.

Rain shortened the match and left us chasing 177 in 14 overs. Our young batter Sanjay Krishnamurthi was playing the innings of his life.

And who came running onto the field with drinks to encourage him? Pat Cummins. The Australian captain, carrying drinks for a young American cricketer in a league game that couldn’t change the standings.

Sanjay went on to score 79 not out and win the match. He later told Cricbuzz how much Pat’s encouragement meant to him.

There was no ego involved. Pat was genuinely excited about a young teammate doing well, and was happy to be the twelfth man helping him.

These are two small personal experiences, but they have influenced my opinion of Pat. Now, back to Sandpapergate.

The original plan

Both Khawaja and Bancroft point to David Warner as the person who proposed using sandpaper. Bancroft even recalls Steve Smith saying, “I don’t want to know about it.”

Think about that for a moment. The Australian captain apparently didn’t want to know what was being planned. Yet Cummins, a 24-year-old fast bowler playing his 13th Test, is now being accused of having full knowldge and also engineering the whole operation. So how did the Australian team implement Smith’s request of “not wanting to know?”. Was he the only one kept out of that knowledge?

I find that particularly implausible. Neither Khawaja’s nor Bancroft’s account establishes that Cummins planned the use of sandpaper, and both identify Warner as the instigator.

There is also the matter of the dressing room itself.

Cummins described a large, fragmented dressing room, with different groups of players having different conversations. Bancroft acknowledges that not everyone was present when sandpaper was first discussed. So the fact that a conversation took place in the dressing room doesn’t establish that everyone heard it.

Even Smith’s reported refusal to know suggests that people had different levels of involvement. We shouldn’t assume everyone possessed the same information.

The designated shiner

This is where I think much of the discussion has gone wrong.

Every cricket team has someone responsible for maintaining the ball. We have a designated shiner even in the club cricket I still play. His job is to maintain one shiny side, after the first over or so the team decides which side to shine and the designated shiner takes care of the ball as much as he can,

Bancroft describes the bowlers giving him feedback on the ball’s movement. He takes this as evidence that they knew what he was doing.

But consider what that feedback actually establishes.

A bowler asking Bancroft whether the ball is reversing tells us that the bowler knew Bancroft was working on the ball. It doesn’t tell us that the bowler knew Bancroft was using sandpaper.

Suppose a bowler asks the designated shiner to do a better job because the ball isn’t reversing. The shiner then uses an illegal method. Does the bowler’s request establish that he knew about the illegal method?

Obviously not.

Bancroft explicitly alleges that the bowlers knew. That allegation deserves to be examined. But the feedback conversations he describes do not, by themselves, establish that knowledge.

An experienced fast bowler might have noticed something unusual about the ball. He might have suspected that someone was doing more than ordinary maintenance. But suspicion and knowledge are different things.

And we should distinguish between knowing that a teammate is working on the ball, knowing he is using an illegal method, and knowing he is carrying sandpaper onto the field.

The umpires’ inspection

There is another piece of evidence that seems to have been forgotten.

When Bancroft was caught on camera in Cape Town, the two on-field umpires, Nigel Llong and Richard Illingworth, inspected the ball. They found no visible damage sufficient to warrant replacing it, and play continued with the same ball.

Think about what that means. Two experienced international umpires, specifically alerted to possible tampering, examined the ball and found nothing that warranted changing it.

Yet we are supposed to believe that the fast bowlers must have known sandpaper was being used simply because they handled the ball regularly?

Of course, the umpires’ inspection doesn’t establish that nobody could have detected anything unusual, or that the ball had never been altered. Bancroft was caught on camera, after all. But it does weaken the argument that the bowlers must have noticed evidence of sandpaper simply by handling the ball.

Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Lyon made precisely this point in their joint statement in 2021. Their position on this has been consistent for five years.

The team culture

Khawaja and Bancroft describe a win-at-all-costs culture in the Australian team. Cummins himself has acknowledged that the team culture in 2018 had problems.

I have no trouble accepting that account. I also have no trouble believing that questionable methods of ball maintenance had become accepted practice in parts of the team.

But there is a logical gap between accepting that a team had a culture of pushing boundaries and concluding that every player knew about a particular act of cheating. Multiple accounts have said the captain exclaimed “I don’t want to know” and it is for that precise failure of leadership Smith took the blame, not for instigating and implementing the plan.

Bancroft’s account describes a collective environment in which cheating became easier to contemplate and carry out. That may well be accurate. But his own description also identifies specific people initiating conversations, others participating, and Smith apparently choosing not to know.

That is not a picture of uniform knowledge.

Cummins’s denials

Cummins’s recent press conference lasted nearly 70 minutes. He faced repeated questions about what he knew, when he knew it, and whether his denials were carefully worded.

He denied knowing that sandpaper would be taken onto the field. He also denied knowing about an illegal ball-tampering plan more generally.

Some have characterized this as clever semantics. Perhaps. But the distinction between ordinary ball maintenance and knowledge of an illegal method is a real one, particularly in cricket where maintaining the ball is a routine activity.

We should also be careful not to stretch his denials beyond what he actually said. Bancroft’s allegations, if corroborated, would contradict Cummins’s account. The question is whether the specific conversations Bancroft recounts establish the necessary knowledge.

I don’t think they do.

Cummins could have known that Bancroft was working aggressively on the ball, could have discussed the need for more reverse swing, and could still have been unaware that sandpaper was being used. Nothing in the routine feedback conversations rules out that possibility.

Of course, this doesn’t prove Cummins was unaware. And Bancroft may have additional evidence that would establish otherwise. But so far we have his assertion of knowledge, alongside descriptions of interactions that also admit an innocent explanation.

I am also struck by the fact that Cummins acknowledged the shortcomings of the old Australian team culture during his press conference. He didn’t attempt to defend everything that happened in 2018. He maintained that he had no knowledge of the illegal scheme.

That position is entirely plausible given the roles described by Khawaja and Bancroft themselves.

The benefit of the doubt

I don’t know what Cummins knew in Cape Town in 2018. Neither my conversations with him nor his conduct at the Unicorns can establish that.

And I am certainly not suggesting that Khawaja or Bancroft have invented their experiences. Their accounts may be substantially accurate.

But there is no contradiction in believing that Warner proposed the scheme, Bancroft carried it out, other players and coaches knew about it, and Cummins remained unaware of the specific illegal activity.

The evidence presented so far doesn’t establish that Cummins is lying.

I’ve criticized him publicly, argued with him personally, and watched him lead when he wasn’t even the designated captain.

I am inclined to give him the benefit of the doubt.

And I don’t think the evidence so far gives me a reason to withdraw it.

, ,